The Photographic idea

This past week I got into a discussion with two local photographers about photography as Art. Their opinion was that photography has become mostly a point-and-shoot process that is really all about documenting one’s personal life.

I think defining Art has always been “in the eye of the beholder”.  

I remember a friend chastising me when I was too critical of a photographer’s image, by saying that all to familiar phrase, “I may not know about Art, but I do know what I like.” 

Ansel Adams, in the forward to his popular 1950’s book “The Print” said, “Photography, in the final analysis, can be reduced to a few simple principles…” and he continued, “Photography is more than a medium for factual communication of ideas. It is a creative art…technique is justified only so far as it will simplify and clarify the statement of the photographer’s concept.”

I remember the series of books by Adams when photography was about striving for the perfect negative and a good final print.

We don’t need to worry about a perfect negative any more, because even if the image file produced in-camera isn’t satisfactory it’s easily colour balanced, cropped, and sharpened later. Contrast can be changed and increasingly, the trend for many photographers has become to not make large prints at all. 

That said, I still think that Adams’ forward in “The Print” may be as worthwhile now as it was in 1950 for a photographer’s Art. Even with the changes of how an image is managed and finally used (whether print or electronic) the thought process is still important. Adams wrote about the technique of taking the picture, the negative, and the printing procedure. He might as well have been talking about transferring image data from a camera to computer, optimizing the files, and outputting to an online portfolio.

Adams wrote, “We may draw an analogy with music: The composer entertains a musical idea. He sets it down in conventional musical notation. When he performs it, he may, although respecting the score, inject personal expressive interpretations on the basic patterns of the notes. So it is in expressive photography: The concept of the photograph precedes the operation of the camera. Exposure and development of the negative…” He continues by saying, “the print itself is somewhat of an interpretation, a performance of the photographic idea.”

I have always liked that final sentence of his “…the print (image file?) itself is somewhat of an interpretation, a performance of the photographic idea.”   Those words remind me not to be as critical of other photographers work, if as Adams put it, “Photography is more than a medium for factual communication of ideas.”

I think what my friend meant when he said, ““I may not know Art, but I do know what I like.”   Was that I should be paying attention to what a photographer might be saying with his or her image and remind myself to think about “interpretation” and the “performance of the photographic idea.”

That is why its good that I still have that somewhat out-dated book, and why I should regularly open it up. After all the prattle about the newest camera, or lens, or computer programs, I need to be brought back to what, in the end, photography is about for me personally.

8 responses to “The Photographic idea

  1. This is so often what I seem to struggle with – I have a photographic idea, but somewhere between what goes on inside my head and what goes on inside my camera in producing the final image some things tend to get lost in translation. So for now the gap between my potential artistic creativity and my technical photographic knowledge and skills still leaves a lot to be desired… but I keep working on it! 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

    • Ah Ruth, that is the struggle one must go through.
      I have been after that creative moment since I was stumbling through assignments during my college photography class I took way back in 1972.
      Although not aways successful, I usually have a plan. I have met some wonderfully creative photographers over the years that make the process seem easy. I will admit that it is not easy for me. However, when an image, a photograph does come together I think it’s because of planning, experience, and years of studying this exciting medium.
      I have never called myself an artist, although some others have and thats darn flattering.
      My advice to you is study, experiment and keep true to your own “Photographic Idea”.

      Liked by 2 people

  2. I really enjoyed this thought-provoking posting, John, and the accompanying photos are incredible. As I have gotten more and more into photography, I have come to realize how much our “documentation” of the world is influenced by the creative choices that we make, whether it is something as simple as the framing of our shots or something more complicated like the series of camera settings or the post-processing of the images. While it is true that many of the photos taken with camera phones merely document the details of someone’s personal life, there is still definitely a place for an artistic vision, an individual view of the world that we want to share with others.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Some great thoughts and images John! Although there may be some professional photographers who enjoy the challenge and stress of creating saleable images, I like the freedom of being an enthusiast who enjoys the discovery and creativity of making all sorts of images and sharing them with curious folks.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.